Why Cyber Resilience Beats Cyber Insurance

The Myth of the Cyber Safety Net

Picture this: a mid-sized Australian business gets hit with a ransomware attack. The owners breathe a sigh of relief knowing they have cyber insurance, assuming the payout will make everything right. Reality check: money might cover some costs, but it won’t revive lost data, restore customer trust, or instantly end downtime. In fact, the aftermath of a breach can be fatal for a small business. One famous statistic warns that 60% of small businesses close within six months of a cyber attack. Insurance or not, a big enough hit can knock you out for good. The lesson? Relying solely on an insurance check is a dangerous myth, a myth that a financial safety net can magically undo the damage of a cyber incident.

The core problem is simple: cyber insurance may pay for some of the fallout, but it doesn’t rewind the clock. It won’t bring back your reputation or the hours of operation you lost. It won’t patch up angry clients or undo a headline-grabbing data breach. Too many business owners discover this too late, after assuming an insurance policy is a get-out-of-jail-free card. It isn’t. Cyber insurance is a band-aid; it’s not a time machine. To truly protect your business, you need to avoid the wound in the first place, or at least heal it quickly and permanently. That’s where cyber resilience comes in.

Cyber Insurance: What It Covers (and What It Doesn’t)

Don’t get us wrong, cyber insurance has its place. A good cyber liability policy can be a lifeline in covering immediate financial costs of an incident. Most Australian cyber insurance policies typically cover things like:

• Forensic investigation of the breach (hiring experts to find out what happened)
• Data restoration and recovery costs (trying to get your data back)
• Legal and notification expenses (lawyers, informing affected customers, PR efforts)
• Regulatory fines or penalties (if regulators come knocking after a data breach)
• Ransomware payments or negotiations (in some cases, reimbursing ransom or hiring negotiators, if legal)

Those are valuable provisions. If you suffer an attack, the policy might pay for forensic IT consultants, cover your required breach notifications and credit monitoring for customers, or even foot the bill for a ransom payout (though paying ransoms is strongly discouraged by authorities). Cyber insurance can also cover business interruption losses for the downtime you experience. In short, it’s meant to cushion the financial blow of an incident.

The catch? In 2024–25, many businesses found that the fine print can bite. Cyber insurance premiums have been rising, and coverage terms are getting stricter. Insurers are tightening what they’ll pay for, and under what conditions. Here are some hard truths about what insurance doesn’t cover or when it falls short:

• Claims denied without proper safeguards: If you didn’t have basic protections in place, your claim may be denied outright. (Did you leave an old server unpatched or skip setting up multi-factor authentication? That could void your coverage.) One insurer recently went to court to void a policy because the client hadn’t actually implemented MFA as they’d claimed. Nearly half of cyber insurance claims get denied due to unmet security requirements or excluded scenarios. Insurers will scrutinise whether you took “reasonable precautions.”
• Common exclusions: Many policies won’t cover incidents caused by sheer negligence or avoidable mistakes. For example, if an employee falls for a phishing scam, some insurers might argue it was preventable human error. Outdated software, poor passwords, lack of staff training – these can all be cited as failures on your part. Some policies also exclude certain types of attacks (like state-sponsored hacking, which might be labeled an “act of war”).
• Reduced coverage limits: In the past couple of years, insurers have been quietly reducing how much they’ll pay for certain categories of loss. There might be sub-limits for ransomware payments or business email compromise losses. You might find that while you’re covered for, say, $1 million overall, there’s a clause that only $100k of that can go toward recovering data or covering regulatory fines. If your actual costs exceed those sub-limits, too bad, you’re on the hook.
• High premiums and tough underwriting: After a spike in costly cyber claims, insurance premiums climbed significantly. While the market has shown some stabilization recently, companies with less mature security face hefty premiums or even refusals. Insurers now often require detailed questionnaires or audits of your cybersecurity practices before issuing a policy. If you can’t prove you’re taking security seriously (think MFA, regular backups, employee training, etc.), you might not qualify for coverage at all. In other words, the era of cheap, no-questions-asked cyber insurance is over.

The takeaway: Cyber insurance is increasingly becoming a “gated” safety net, you only get the benefit if you’ve done your homework on security. And even when it pays, it pays money, not reputation or lost time. You get funds to help you clean up the mess, but the mess still happens. This is why more business leaders are shifting their focus to cyber resilience as a first line of defense.

The Case for Cyber Resilience

So, what exactly is “cyber resilience”? In plain English, it’s your company’s ability to keep operating through a cyber attack and bounce back quickly. The Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC) defines cyber resilience as the ability to adapt to disruptions caused by cyber incidents while maintaining continuous business operations. In practice, that means not just trying to prevent attacks, but also being ready to detect, respond, and recover when (not if) one slips through.

Think of it this way: Insurance is the band-aid. Resilience is the immune system. A band-aid (insurance) might cover a wound after the damage is done. An immune system (resilience) works to fend off threats and heal the body, ideally before severe damage occurs. Cyber resilience is about having the strength and plans in place to withstand assaults on your IT systems so that your business stays standing no matter what.

Real cyber resilience is proactive and multi-layered. It includes all the measures that make your organisation harder to breach and quicker to recover. Here’s a short checklist of what resilience looks like in action:

• 24/7 monitoring and alerting: Constant oversight of your network (e.g. a Security Operations Center watching for intrusions) so threats are caught immediately.
• Regular backups and DR tests: Daily or continuous data backups, plus disaster recovery (DR) drills to ensure you can restore systems and data quickly if something goes wrong. (Backups are no good if you’ve never tested restoring them!)
• Incident response playbooks: A rehearsed plan for cyber incidents, detailing who does what when an attack happens. This playbook approach means your team isn’t scrambling cluelessly during a crisis – they have a script to follow to contain damage fast.
• Employee phishing training: Humans are often the weakest link. Regular security awareness training helps employees spot suspicious emails and avoid falling for scams. One well-trained employee can thwart a phishing attempt that might have otherwise led to a major breach.
• Layered security tools (MFA, EDR, SIEM, etc.): No single tool stops all threats. Resilience means deploying multiple defenses: Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) to lock down logins, Endpoint Detection & Response (EDR) on devices to catch malware, and security monitoring systems like SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) to correlate alerts. Plus basics like firewalls, antivirus, and vulnerability patching, all working in concert.

In short, cyber resilience is a culture and architecture of preparedness. It’s assuming that breaches can happen despite your best prevention efforts, and designing your business to minimize the impact. This way, even if attackers land a punch, it’s a glancing blow, not a knockout.

‍

‍Why Resilience Wins (with ROI in Mind)

Investing in cyber resilience isn’t just an IT tactic; it’s a smart business strategy. Yes, it requires up-front effort and budget, but the return on investment can be seen in real-world outcomes. Let’s break down why resilience beats insurance when it comes to business continuity and ROI:

Downtime Kills Faster Than Hackers

When a cyber incident strikes, the clock starts ticking. Every hour of downtime is lost revenue, lost productivity, and a hit to your brand. Studies show that downtime from cyber attacks costs businesses tens of thousands of dollars per hour on average. Imagine your e-commerce site, your reservation system, or your office IT being down for days – it’s often an existential threat. Many businesses simply can’t afford to be offline for a week while they sort out a breach. Cyber resilience directly addresses this by reducing downtime. If you can quickly isolate affected systems and fail over to backups, that ransomware that took out your server might only cause a 30-minute blip instead of a 3-week shutdown. The ROI is clear: less downtime = less loss. In fact, avoiding a single day of halted operations could save more money than a year’s worth of security investments. You can always earn back money, but you can’t recover lost time with customers and operations.

You Can’t Insure Reputation

One of the most devastating (and intangible) costs of a cyberattack is reputational damage. Customers, partners, and even employees may lose faith in your business after a major breach. No insurance policy can buy back the trust of your clientele once it’s been shaken. Think about it: would you readily continue banking with an institution that leaked your personal data, or shopping at an online store that exposed your credit card info? Surveys have found that a significant percentage of customers will stop doing business with a company after a data breach. This erosion of confidence can hurt your revenue far into the future. Cyber resilience helps you protect your reputation by preventing breaches or containing them so effectively that customers see you taking quick, responsible action. By stopping incidents before they spiral into public disasters, you’re essentially insuring your reputation through good security. In today’s market, being able to say “we take security seriously”, and proving it, is a competitive advantage. Conversely, if you end up in headlines for a breach, no payout can fully repair the brand damage done.

Recovery Time = Survival Rate

There’s a direct correlation between how fast you recover and whether your business survives a cyber incident. We already noted that a majority of small businesses that suffer a severe cyber attack never reopen. It’s not hard to see why: if it takes you months to rebuild systems, notify customers, deal with regulators, and get back to “business as usual,” you might bleed out before reaching the finish line. IBM’s latest research found that only about 12% of organizations achieve full recovery even long after a data breach, meaning nearly 9 out of 10 are still dealing with lingering effects or have not returned to normal. The sooner you can close the incident and restore operations, the higher your chance to fully bounce back (and avoid becoming another statistic). Cyber resilience measures like incident response drills, redundant systems, and cloud failovers dramatically shrink recovery time. It’s the difference between absorbing a punch and getting back up versus being down for the count. Businesses that plan and practice for incidents tend to recover far faster than those that wing it. Faster recovery not only saves money, it might save the entire company.

Insurers Now Demand Proof of Cyber Hygiene

Here’s an ironic twist: being cyber resilient isn’t just good for its own sake, it’s now required if you even want cyber insurance. Insurers have wised up; they now treat insurance as a “test of cyber readiness,” to quote one industry report. In Australia, many insurers demand that businesses meet certain baseline security controls (often six or more) before coverage is offered. They want to see things like email security filtering, identity & access management (MFA), up-to-date patching, 24/7 monitoring, and offline backups as standard. Essentially, you need to prove your cyber hygiene to get the policy. Even after you’re insured, if you let your guard down and skip those practices, your claims could be rejected. This trend will only continue as insurance underwriters study claim data – companies with better resilience have fewer incidents and lower payouts, so they’re preferred customers. The takeaway: resilience isn’t just good for you, it’s becoming mandatory. Smart businesses treat insurance as a last resort, not a first line of defense. The new standard is security-first; insurance second.

‍

The New Standard: Cyber Insurance + Resilience

Forward-thinking organizations now adopt a blended strategy: use insurance as a supplement, not a substitute, for strong cybersecurity. In practical terms, that means building a layered defense model where cyber insurance is the final layer of risk mitigation, the financial buffer after you’ve done everything possible to protect and prepare your business. A resilient company’s approach might look like this:

1. Prevention: Start with robust preventive measures to keep attackers out. This includes next-generation firewalls, antivirus/anti-malware on all devices, network segmentation, strict access controls, and of course MFA on all critical accounts. You aim to reduce the chance of an incident in the first place.
2. Detection: Assume some threats will slip past prevention, so set up early-warning systems. Deploy intrusion detection systems and SIEM tools, and have a 24/7 Security Operations Center (in-house or via a provider) to watch for anomalies. The goal is to catch breaches immediately and respond before they spread.
3. Recovery: Prepare for the worst-case scenario, that a breach or outage does occur. This is where backup and disaster recovery planning is vital. Keep secure, frequent backups of data (with offline copies immune to ransomware). Develop a disaster recovery plan that covers how to restore systems, in what order, and where (e.g. spinning up in a cloud environment if your servers go down). Even practice this plan with drills. When you’re resilient, getting hit doesn’t mean going down; you have safe data and alternate systems ready to go.
4. Insurance: Finally, maintain a cyber insurance policy as the safety net for financial losses you couldn’t prevent. This covers those residual risks, maybe a sophisticated attack still manages to cause damage or a lawsuit arises from a breach. You use insurance to handle costs that your security measures can’t eliminate, like legal claims or regulatory fines. Importantly, because you’ve done steps 1–3, you not only reduce the likelihood of ever needing to file a claim, but if you do, you’re more likely to collect because you’ve met all the policy’s security requirements.

The layered model above illustrates that insurance is just one part of a holistic resilience strategy. Each layer supports the others. By the time you “need” that insurance payout, ideally your proactive efforts have already limited the damage. As a bonus, many insurers will offer better rates or coverage if you can demonstrate strong preventive and recovery capabilities. In essence, cyber resilience and cyber insurance now go hand-in-hand, but resilience must lead the way.

‍‍
Inlight’s Approach: Resilience by Design

At Inlight IT, we’ve built our entire cybersecurity philosophy around resilience by design. We believe that businesses should never have to rely on an insurance claim to save them, instead, they should architect their IT to withstand attacks and keep running. How do we do that? By integrating prevention, detection, and recovery measures into every solution we deliver. Inlight offers a suite of managed services that together create a robust shield for your organisation:

• Managed Cybersecurity Stack: We provide a complete layered defense as your managed security partner. That means next-gen firewalls, intrusion prevention, endpoint protection (EDR), and multi-factor authentication across your environment, all configured and monitored by our experts. Our 24/7 Security Operations Centre watches over your systems, alerting and responding to threats in real time. We also conduct regular vulnerability assessments and simulated attacks (penetration testing) to pinpoint and fix weaknesses before attackers find them. And let’s not forget your people: we include ongoing cyber awareness training to empower your staff as an active part of your defense. By covering technology and humans, we dramatically lower your risk of incidents.
• Backup & Disaster Recovery Solutions: Inlight’s Backup and DR services (our “Continuity Shield”) ensure that even if the worst happens, your data and operations can be restored with minimal disruption. We set up automated, encrypted backups for both cloud and on-prem systems, with offsite storage so ransomware can’t touch them. Crucially, we don’t just set it and forget it – we perform regular disaster recovery drills and testing of backups. This means when there’s a hardware failure, cyber attack, or even just human error data loss, we already know the recovery process will work. Our clients can recover full systems or critical files in minutes, not days, slashing downtime. One Inlight client, for example, faced a server ransomware encryption, but we had them back up and running from a clean backup within an hour, avoiding days of shutdown and no ransom paid.
• Cloud Continuity Architecture: We design your IT infrastructure with continuity in mind. That could mean setting up cloud-based failover systems, clustering critical applications across multiple locations, or leveraging high-availability architectures. Essentially, we make sure there’s no single point of failure. If one server or site goes down, your workloads automatically shift to another, so your customers and employees experience zero interruption. This kind of resilience by design keeps your business online even during incidents that would sink others.
• Cyber Compliance and Readiness: Resilience isn’t just about tech, it’s also about meeting the growing compliance demands. Inlight helps you align with frameworks like the Australian Essential Eight, ISO 27001, and industry-specific regulations. We map security controls to compliance requirements, so you can confidently tick the boxes for things like data protection, incident response, and continuity planning. When regulators or big clients ask for proof of your cybersecurity posture, you’ll have it at your fingertips. The side effect of being compliant is being secure – and vice versa. It’s all part of the resilience package.

The outcome of this holistic approach is clear: less downtime, less worry, and more business-as-usual. With Inlight as your proactive partner, you’re not fighting fires reactively. You’re preventing many incidents from happening in the first place, and you’re fully prepared to handle the ones that do. We like to say our mission is to keep clients out of the news. If breaches do occur, they become footnotes, not front-page disasters. And beyond just surviving, our clients often find that robust security and continuity translate into positive business outcomes – their customers trust them more, and they sleep easier at night knowing the business is safe. That’s the power of resilience by design.

‍

Final Thoughts: Don’t Just Survive. Stay Standing.

In today’s cyber threat landscape, hope is not a strategy and insurance is not a cure-all. Every business, from a five-person startup to a 500-person enterprise, is a potential target for cyber attacks. The differentiator is how you prepare and respond. Cyber resilience gives you the upper hand by making your business adaptable and tougher to knock down. Rather than gambling on an insurance payout after catastrophe strikes, you’re investing in not having a catastrophe in the first place – or being able to shrug it off quickly if it happens. It’s the difference between surviving and thriving in the face of cyber adversity.

The message is clear: don’t wait until you’re in the middle of a crisis to figure out how to respond. By then, the damage is done and an insurance check will feel like cold comfort. Instead, take control now. Build a strong immune system for your organisation. Empower your team, fortify your systems, and rehearse your recovery. Not only will you drastically reduce the chances of a devastating breach, you’ll also sleep better knowing that even if bad luck strikes, it won’t break your business.

In the showdown of cyber resilience vs. cyber insurance, think of resilience as the long-term fitness plan and insurance as the ambulance. You want the fitness plan to keep you healthy and out of the hospital. Use the ambulance only if you absolutely must. In the end, cyber insurance can reimburse losses. Cyber resilience keeps your business alive. And keeping your business alive and thriving is the ultimate goal.

‍
Ready to build real cyber resilience?

Explore Inlight’s Cybersecurity and Backup & DR solutions to safeguard your business before the next headline hits. Book a Security Review and let’s fortify your future.

Submit a form below or feel free to read more on our Cybersecurity page.